The foresight gap: What too many organizations get wrong

by John Mahaffie on September 17, 2014

6THBusinesses aim close. Too often, a business’s view stays on its current realities and where the business is excelling or struggling. The mindset is near-term and management aligns its tools to support that near-term view. This creates a gulf between the challenges and opportunities of the future and the demands of the status quo. It is a foresight gap.

The problem is endemic. Business rewards executives for improving the current business model and processes, but too rarely for charting a smart future course. Businesses measure results with tools which lock them in to present-focused, incremental improvement. That leaves out positive action around change that will shape their destiny in the longer term.

Ideas and behavior around risk create the foresight gap. Baseball offers an analogy. Sometimes a ballplayer who tries to do something hard, like catching a ball that requires him to lunge far to one side, fails at his attempt. The umpires give him an error for not catching the ball. Another, less risk-taking player might not try for the tough catch at all, letting it go by. And then the umpires may not award an error, presuming the ball was un-catchable. The game punishes risk taking and rewards risk avoidance. Business is like that.

As in baseball, businesses tend to punish risk takers when things do not work out. But they reward executives who stay the course. And though staying the course is a poor futures strategy, the business considers taking a longer-term view to be a move into uncertain and risky ground. The business instinct is to pull back from that longer view. Thus the rewards and measures of success are misaligned.

The foresight gap is rooted in these ingrained habits. But it is also true that business leaders often do not know enough about how to look at the future, nor what to do about what they see on their five-, ten-, or twenty-year horizon. That incomplete knowledge leaves them not understanding what foresight is, how to use it, and what to expect from it.

We need to adjust three critical factors to close the foresight gap:

First, we need to encourage a longer view. The conversation in any organization should sometimes be about five, ten, and twenty years hence. That does not leave behind the present and its tactical needs. But it begins to connect the organization’s longer-term success with present action. The future view gives present action a direction other than simple continuity, and it helps business reevaluate, at intervals, its present course.

And what is that future view like? It is an understanding of a range of possibility which must be less sure the further into the future the business looks. But uncertainty about that future should not shut down a consideration of the possibilities.

Second, a business needs to recognize the executives who take a longer-term view for their wisdom, and not put them under suspicion for embracing what is uncertain or unpredictable. Business needs to get comfortable with acting without complete certainty; it is not possible to make good strategy otherwise. The executive who thinks about the future should get validation and the ear of colleagues. But better still; develop the instinct for the long-term view across the leadership of the organization.

Third, the organization needs to get good at monitoring, interpreting, and responding to change. Any organization has a radar screen. That screen by default shows the things that are obvious and clear for the organization: its operations, constituencies, markets, partners and allies, customers, etc. The executive who attends the sector’s conferences, reads the sector’s newsletters, and so on looks like a good leader. But there is a second radar screen that represents the long view and the future success of the organization, and too few organizations have one. That second screen shows future social, economic, and technological changes that have not yet impacted the organization, but will.

Closing the foresight gap means establishing that second radar screen. It means opening up thinking to allow in things that are not yet shaping the business. It means letting in speculative views of possibilities, even when they do not match current thinking and current understanding of the sector or marketplace the organization plays in. Some part of strategic thinking will always be conjecture, and some part of it will always be rooted in a range of possibilities without the surety of prediction.

The foresight gap needs closing, and smart organizations will work to close it by getting smarter about the future, but also by loosening the tight reins they hold on themselves and their leaders. And those organizations will be the ones that win in the long term.

Image: Cathy T, via Flickr, Creative Commons Attribution License.

{ 1 comment }

Future of Education: Nine Skills That Will Help Make Our Children Future-Ready is the third piece I've done for the World Innovation Summit for Education's online news and idea site: WISE.Ed.Review. My focus for them is on clear future views of what's possible and desireable in education in our future.

Previous pieces:

Exploring the Future for Education: Three Scenarios for 2025

MOOCs, Mobile, and the Future of Higher Education


Exploring the Future for Education: Three Scenarios for 2025

July 8, 2014

Exploring the Future for Education: Three Scenarios for 2025 is the second piece I've done for the World Innovation Summit for Education's online news and idea site, WISE Ed.Review. My focus for them is on clear future views of what's possible and desireable in education in our future. More to come!

Read the full article →

MOOCs, Mobile and the Future of Higher Education

June 27, 2014

Here is a piece I wrote for the World Innovation Summit for Education: MOOCs, Mobile and the Future of Higher Education I expect to write a series of pieces at WISE's online publication in the coming months. Stayed tuned there for great insights on education from me and others!

Read the full article →

The clean slate scenario

May 22, 2014

What would you build today if you started from scratch? This is a question people in organizations, business sectors, government agencies, communities, non-profits, and philanthropies can ask to get new insights on their futures. We can't expect to throw over the old system and get just what we want, but we can free our thinking to understand […]

Read the full article →

Hey futurist, represent!

May 16, 2014

If foresight is a good thing, if knowing a little more about the future we face helps us all, then we ought to be willing to live and play the role of futurist. We ought to out ourselves, with everyone, and represent the future view. What does it mean to "represent" as a futurist? Use […]

Read the full article →

In the future, there’ll be cheesecake

May 7, 2014

If you are like me, when you crave a treat, it's often cheesecake. And though I have, a time or two, made my own cheesecake, I mostly just want marvelous, taste-pleasing cheesecake. I don't care how you make it.  Cheesecake is a whole which need not be understood in its parts. Don't bore me with the […]

Read the full article →

How to break free of difficult history

April 29, 2014

Difficult history is a historical legacy, often of conflict, that still shapes our behavior and interactions. In the United States, there are the lingering effects of the Civil War, even 150 years later, with its legacy in Federal/state and sometimes, North/South distrust, and the history and legacy of slavery. In post-apartheid South Africa, there is […]

Read the full article →

The unspoken scenario

April 24, 2014

Consider for a moment what would happen if you lost everything you own and all your money. That awful scenario is, of course, possible in any of our lives. And no one wants to dwell on such a thought. It would be hideous. But try out the scenario. What would you do that first morning? You and […]

Read the full article →

7 first steps for building an organization’s foresight

April 14, 2014

Are you in a place where you want to kick-start foresight, but you are not sure how to start? You can start simple and you can succeed. But you probably can’t just leap in with a big splash, even if you’re the chief. You need to lay some groundwork. Below are seven ways to get […]

Read the full article →